ChrisA wrote:smiles wrote:
It's not bad. Bit desperately varied in parts. Nice intro and nice chorus then kind of goes down hill before picking up again towards the end. The choice of singer doesn't help either. With all the local talent we have here in Kintyre it wouldn't have been hard to find someone who can actually pronounce loch and Bellochantuy correctly. That's just a bit of constructive critcism Chris. All in all a good effort.
I've been doing this stuff too long to worry about music reviews, all objective after all. But i'd just like to mention a couple of things. There is nothing 'desperate' about the variances at all. It's less a 'song' than a short musical journey, and I've found that people who do like the track, like it precisely because of the many melodic variants in there. Rewards are to be had on repeated plays. It would have been a lot easier to just link the more instantly catchy bits together and do a 3 minute pop song, but that wasn't the idea behind this particular concept.
As for the vcocalist, aye. I see what you are saying BUT .... bear in mind that the vocalist's perspective is not from kintyre, but from elsewhere. He's an outsider. It''s a visitors song, extolling the virutes of a wonderful place.
Finally, maybe have a listen to (Back To) The Kintyre Way (link at bottom) from the same EP. This is a solo piano rendition of the melodies from the main track and may give you a better perspective on its merits. (And this may also appeal more to you as well Isa).
Thanks for listening though.
http://chrisamusic.bandcamp.com/track/b ... intyre-way
Don't get me wrong Chris, it grows on you. Well done.





