by general jack o'niell » Sat Aug 11, 2007 11:11 am
his opinions are one thing, which 99% of the time i don't agree with, the facts are another, i would assume that he didn't just pick the sums out of thin air? fact, there are no subsidies paid to the fishing industry, the £24 million for decommissioning was the total, for the whole of the UK, spread over three years, not a lot when you consider that to replace these same boats would cost at least £200 million.
fishermen were paid a fixed price set by size and tonnage, not market value, there are no set aside payments, if an area is closed its closed, look at the irish skipper in the local paper fined for fishing in a closed area of the clyde, i never knew there was such a thing? i have a rough idea of where it may be, but that could be miles out, the area i had in mind was a staple fishing ground for kintyre and ayrshire boats throughout the year, now it gets shut!!!
farmers get paid not to work land, fishermen get nothing, as it should be most would agree, a small shopkeeper doesn't get a subsidy to compete with the big supermarket, farmers shouldn't either, but then they should also get a fair price for t heir crops, milk, beef etc its no laughing matter when it costs more to produce the milk than they get paid for it, especially as its often used as a loss leader by the big chains.
i couldn't afford to buy fresh fish or prawns or clams etc yet the quay prices are the same as they were thirty years ago, which was the same price as it was ten years previous to that!!!
no wonder half the crews are from eastern europe, nobody will work under these circumstances nowadays, not looking for special treatment, devolve responsibility to holyrood for a start and a level playing field with farmers, see how that would be recieved, with glee by the scottish fishing industry(i know there will be, only the owners would benefit, the crews would get nothing responses) the farmers? they'd be up in arms in case they lost money. it is called the department of agriculture and fisheries, its just the last bit gets mumbled with a hand across the mouth when the money is handed out.
i know farmers have concerns regarding loss of euro money with the new eatern european countries joining, well welcome to the club, scottish fleets have been getting cut for years while the likes of france,spain and portugal have been handing out grants for new builds.